New Yorkers who relocated to Texas and Florida are finding that their savings have decreased-Report

The narrative of New Yorkers packing up for sunnier, tax-friendlier climes has evolved. Initially hailed as a financially savvy exodus, the recent migration to Florida and Texas has revealed a less rosy reality. As the dust settles, former New Yorkers are confronting the truth that the anticipated cost savings have significantly dwindled, particularly when juxtaposed against the situation just four years prior.

This shift has been meticulously documented in a recent study by SmartAsset, highlighting that the once wide economic chasm between living in New York and the southern states of Florida and Texas is narrowing. For example, individuals moving from New York to Miami, who once enjoyed a substantial decrease in living costs, are now facing a starkly different financial landscape.

A New Yorker with an annual income of $250,000 who relocated to Miami last year would find themselves with savings of $88,036—a 28% drop compared to the savings enjoyed by those who made the move in 2019.

Similar trends are unfolding in Texas, particularly in the cities of Austin and Dallas, which were once heralded as bastions of affordability. The savings for the same New Yorker moving to Austin fell by 25% from $154,564 in 2019 to $116,195 in the last year. Dallas also witnessed a decline, albeit slightly less drastic, with savings dropping 20% from $135,887 to $108,208 within the same timeframe.

These dwindling savings are not occurring in a vacuum. They reflect a broader trend of rising living costs in these southern hotspots. Rents in Miami have surged by around 40% since the onset of the pandemic. Similarly, Austin and Dallas have seen significant hikes in both rent and home prices. This surge in real estate costs, coupled with increases in energy, utilities, and gas prices, is reshaping the economic landscape of these cities.

Conversely, New York City, specifically Manhattan, has witnessed more modest increases in living costs. Rent has risen by just 3.3% from 2019 to 2023, and although home prices have seen a significant jump, the overall pace of living cost increases is less stark compared to its southern counterparts.

This financial shift is particularly poignant when considering state income taxes. New York State stands as the third highest in the nation, while Florida and Texas benefit from the absence of a state income tax. This disparity initially offered substantial savings for transplants. However, the surging real estate market has led to increased property taxes in Texas and a severe property insurance crisis in Florida, eroding the financial benefits of relocation.

The demographic changes underscored by recent census data provide context to these economic shifts. New York, alongside other high-cost cities like Chicago and Los Angeles, has seen significant population decreases, with more than half a million people leaving New York since 2020. The beneficiaries of this migratory trend have primarily been cities in Texas, such as Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston, which have seen substantial population increases.

Yet, despite the escalating costs, the influx of people into these southern states continues, driven by factors beyond mere economic calculus. The appeal of better weather, perceived quality of life improvements, and cultural shifts play significant roles in this ongoing migration.

As Michael Martirena, a luxury real estate advisor, notes, the continued acceptance of increased costs across various sectors by new residents suggests a recalibration of what constitutes the ‘new normal’ in living standards.

The tale of New Yorkers moving to Florida and Texas is, therefore, not just a story of seeking financial haven but a complex narrative involving changing costs, shifting demographics, and evolving lifestyles. As these trends continue to unfold, the true cost of seeking a sunnier life away from the Big Apple becomes increasingly nuanced, challenging former residents to reassess the real value of their southern odyssey.

About the author

Author description olor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed pulvinar ligula augue, quis bibendum tellus scelerisque venenatis. Pellentesque porta nisi mi. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Etiam risus elit, molestie 

Leave a Comment